IMPORTANT ADVICE FOR OUR CLIENTS WITH WEBSITES
There’s been an alarming rise in Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”) website-related lawsuits. These litigious claims are driven by a combination of a few things: recently updated ADA guidelines, the failure of quick-fix software apps and widgets and, worse still, the repeated claims by highly motivated serial plaintiffs and law firms who target small business over minor, auto-detected website errors. Our concern over this potential disruptive cost to your business is why we want you to make sure your business website is ADA compliant.
An Alarming Trend
The ADA is a civil rights law that prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities in all areas of public life. This includes both direct discrimination, where individuals are treated less favorably because of a disability, and indirect discrimination, where discrimination is less obvious or unintended. Currently there are approximately 6,000 lawsuits (up from 4,000 in 2024) filed in federal and state courts by individuals with visual, hearing, or other disabilities, alleging that companies’ websites and mobile applications failed to comply with Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). These individuals claimed the websites and mobile apps had digital “barriers” (such as include incompatibility with screen-reader software, missing captions or transcripts for video and audio content, insufficient color contrast, broken links, pop-ups, widgets and/or plug-ins creating keyboard navigation errors) that prevented them from effectively navigating company websites to enjoy the “goods and services” of those companies. Because most websites are created to be accessible to the general public, it puts them at risk for one of these increasingly prevalent lawsuits.
Lawsuit Defenses
Even the smallest companies with an online presence are at risk of suit, and those who also have a physical presence are at an even higher risk. However, this does not mean businesses are without defenses. Because a recent lawsuit merely resulted in requiring a company to remediate its website’s accessibility issues, every company should preemptively adopt and publish an accessibility policy statement and plan to ensure its website is accessible. Any published plan should include steps the company will take to address known or unknown issues and an estimated timeline to completion. Publishing an accessibility policy or statement on your website lets your website’s users know you take digital inclusion seriously and provides a direct contact method if someone encounters an accessibility barrier.
And remember, it is the plaintiff’s burden to prove they suffered an “injury in fact” to be entitled to injunctive relief based upon their “intent to return” to a particular website. In many of these cases, the plaintiffs fail to plead these facts, leaving the case susceptible to a motion to dismiss.
A Special Note to Our California Clients
California businesses have been facing a rising wave of state court lawsuits alleging their websites violate the Unruh Civil Rights Act by being inaccessible to visitors with disabilities. Unlike federal ADA claims, California’s Unruh Act allows plaintiffs to seek statutory damages of at least $4,000 per violation, making these cases especially costly for small and medium-sized businesses. For this reason, many plaintiffs’ attorneys prefer filing an action in a California state court. Plus California courts have found websites that fail to meet ADA accessibility standards can bolster Unruh Act claim. Bottom line…you can help prevent or minimize the cost of these litigious actions by acting quickly with legal counsel and performing a website ADA compliance and accessibility audit.
Recommended Action to Protect Your Business
As a practical matter, companies need to ensure their internal and external web developers, and others creating content, understand accessibility issues. Companies need a reputable outside firm to assist and do periodic testing. But buyer beware…there are companies marketing quick, cheap fixes, which means there is no substitute for making website content ADA accessible at the code level. Here’s a link to the ADA website that gives guidance on web accessibility: ADA Web Resources
